CARDSPEED - Card Readers and Memory Cards

Memory Stick PRO-HG

For a long time, there were exactly three cards available: SONY MS PRO-HG Duo as 1GB MS-EX1G, 2GB MS-EX2G and 4GB MS-EX4G.

SanDisk was involved in the original press release from December 2006 announcing the MS PRO-HG, but it took until May 2008 until they announced the first series. Although their Extreme IV line with 40MB/s read/write would be the appropriate speed range, the first series will be the SanDisk Extreme III Memory Stick PRO-HG Duo as 4GB SDMSHX3-004G-A31 and 8GB SDMSHX3-008G-A31 with a claimed read/write speed of 30MB/s.

As of June 2008, that makes a total of five cards available, with sizes from 1GB to 8GB.

Quick links:    Information   ·   Express/34 Adapter   ·   SONY   ·   SanDisk   ·   USB Readers 

General Information

Memory Stick PRO-HG will currently be available in Duo size only. Compared to the Memory Stick PRO, the maximum clock rate is raised from 40MHz to 60MHz, while the bus width is doubled from 4bit to 8bit. This is done by using longer pads of about 6.3mm length instead of about 4.8mm length. The previous four data pads are then split up in a front half and a rear half to double the bus width. These two measures raise the theoretical data rate from 19MB/s to 57MB/s.

Memory Stick PRO-HG Duo Pads

The Memory Stick PRO-HG will be fully compatible with existing Memory Stick PRO devices at up to 40MHz and 4bit bus width. This means that a Memory Stick PRO-HG will act exactly as a regular Memory Stick PRO when used with a decive that is not aware of the Memory Stick PRO-HG standard.

SONY Memory Stick PRO-HG Duo ExpressCard 34 Adapter

While all previous ExpressCard based Card Readers only used the USB 2.0 link of the ExpressCard interface, the SONY MSAC-EX1 is a true PCIe x1 adapter with a theroretical bandwidth of about 238MB/s.

The adapter identifies as "Sony Memory Stick Duo ExpressCard Adaptor", shows up as PCI device PCI\VEN_104D&DEV_8211&REV_00, and is handled by the service "SonyEXMS" using SonyEXMS.sys.

First tests with the  MS-EX4G PRO-HG Duo  already showed data rates of up to 37.9MB/s, which would not be possible with a USB 2.0 card reader. For further test results, see the  MSAC-EX1 Test Results  Page.

SONY Memory Stick PRO-HG Duo 4GB

While the SONY Memory Stick PRO previously stayed well behind the SanDisk models, the new SONY Memory Stick PRO-HG Duo claim data rates of 30MB/s.

Tests with the MSAC-EX1 Express/34 adapter and the  MS-EX4G MS PRO-HG Duo 4GB  even showed an average read rate of 37.75MB/s and an average write rate of 30.31MB/s. For details regarding the maximum performance of the card, see the  MS-EX4G Page .

SanDisk Extreme III Memory Stick PRO-HG Duo 8GB

For PRO-HG, SanDisk upgraded the Extreme III line from slightly overrated 18MB/s to claimed 30MB/s.

Tests with the MSAC-EX1 Express/34 adapter and the  SanDisk Extreme III MS PRO-HG Duo 8GB  even showed an average read rate of 40.94MB/s and an average write rate of 41.80MB/s. Once again, SanDisk takes the lead in speed.

For details regarding the maximum performance of the card, see the  SDMSHX3 Page .

USB 2.0 Card Readers

Of course, Memory Stick PRO-HG can be read with any Memory Stick PRO device. Tests with current card readers without MS PRO-HG support showed read rates of about 16MB/s and write rates of about 14MB/s.

The  Digisol 47100/47110  models are the first retail models with full MS PRO-HG support. The regular file read/write tests showed about 33MB/s read and about 24MB/s write. The maximum rates without filesystem involved will be taken later.


Hans-Jürgen Reggel   ·   http://www.hjreggel.net/cardspeed/   ·   2007-10-03 ~ 2008-06-30