CARDSPEED - Card Readers and Memory Cards

Card		c't h2benchw			c't h2benchw			hjreggel cardcheck
Reader	Controller	read [MB/s]			access [ms]			read			write
Transcend CF 300x 16GB		min.	max.	avg.	min.	max.	avg.	avg. [MB/s]	150 kB/s	chk	avg. [MB/s]	150 kB/s	chk	Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	44.04 ~	47.16	46.50	0.15 ~	0.58	0.25	51.44	351.1×	OK	33.52	228.8×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	45.22 ~	48.68	47.98	0.15 ~	0.50	0.24	50.75	346.4×	OK	33.56	229.1×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	30.42 ~	33.33	32.56	0.38 ~	1.01	0.58	31.76	216.8×	OK	22.55	153.9×	OK
Express/54 USB CF	xSil251:2.23	30.36 ~	33.33	32.62	0.47 ~	1.00	0.58	31.73	216.6×	OK	22.54	153.8×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	30.39 ~	33.33	33.00	0.37 ~	2.60	0.50	31.48	214.8×	OK	22.56	154.0×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	25.67 ~	27.77	27.12	0.47 ~	1.01	0.61	27.61	188.4×	OK	22.27	152.0×	OK
GL826 Sample	GL826:9714	Fail			Fail			Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Card not recognized
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	Fail			Fail			Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Card not recognized
Kingston 19 in 1	GL826:9715	Fail			Fail			Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Fail	Card not recognized
A-Data 266x CF 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	37.68 ~	43.93	42.11	0.17 ~	1.26	0.57	46.69	318.7×	OK	25.06	171.0×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	38.76 ~	45.31	43.30	0.16 ~	0.84	0.57	45.84	312.9×	OK	24.04	164.1×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	29.84 ~	33.33	32.79	0.48 ~	3.10	0.86	31.23	213.1×	OK	20.73	141.5×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	28.92 ~	33.35	32.86	0.47 ~	2.96	0.85	31.15	212.6×	OK	21.02	143.4×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	28.62 ~	33.33	32.34	0.46 ~	1.30	0.88	31.14	212.5×	OK	20.79	141.8×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	26.98 ~	31.17	29.38	0.48 ~	3.47	0.91	29.87	203.8×	OK	22.13	151.0×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	25.66 ~	29.41	28.42	0.49 ~	1.38	0.95	28.00	191.1×	OK	20.07	136.9×	OK
Transcend CF 266x 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	38.13 ~	42.12	41.27	0.15 ~	1.25	0.48	44.80	305.8×	OK	30.44	207.7×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	39.18 ~	43.54	42.93	0.14 ~	0.90	0.46	44.25	302.1×	OK	28.44	194.1×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	29.03 ~	31.28	31.19	0.38 ~	1.13	0.80	31.16	212.6×	OK	22.58	154.1×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	28.73 ~	31.63	31.11	0.35 ~	2.98	0.73	31.10	212.2×	OK	23.08	157.5×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	28.81 ~	33.31	31.63	0.37 ~	2.85	0.73	31.09	212.2×	OK	22.95	156.6×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	27.23 ~	29.48	29.23	0.42 ~	3.35	0.83	28.82	196.7×	OK	24.19	165.1×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	24.63 ~	26.32	26.26	0.49 ~	1.26	0.83	26.26	179.2×	OK	22.11	150.9×	OK
Kingston CF 266x 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	37.03 ~	40.99	40.18	0.16 ~	0.95	0.49	43.61	297.7×	OK	30.05	205.1×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	38.48 ~	42.36	41.74	0.15 ~	1.06	0.47	43.09	294.1×	OK	29.23	199.5×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	28.90 ~	31.28	31.18	0.36 ~	1.37	0.81	31.13	212.5×	OK	22.34	152.4×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	28.90 ~	31.55	31.10	0.37 ~	2.85	0.76	31.10	212.2×	OK	22.85	155.9×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	29.26 ~	31.74	31.13	0.37 ~	2.85	0.75	31.08	212.2×	OK	23.12	157.8×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	27.16 ~	29.52	29.26	0.38 ~	3.34	0.83	28.30	193.1×	OK	24.23	165.3×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	23.40 ~	25.09	24.95	0.49 ~	1.26	0.84	24.95	170.3×	OK	22.09	150.8×	OK
SanDisk CF Ducati 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	39.23 ~	39.64	39.52	0.23 ~	0.78	0.39	43.27	295.4×	OK	39.00	266.2×	OK
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	38.26 ~	38.56	38.43	0.24 ~	1.14	0.40	42.92	292.9×	OK	38.74	264.4×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	31.01 ~	31.29	31.22	0.50 ~	1.05	0.71	31.14	212.6×	OK	25.07	171.1×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	29.73 ~	33.06	32.85	0.48 ~	2.73	0.63	31.09	212.2×	OK	25.02	170.7×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	29.80 ~	33.04	32.59	0.50 ~	2.85	0.63	31.08	212.1×	OK	25.02	170.8×	OK
GL826 Sample	GL826:9714	29.03 ~	29.70	29.30	0.50 ~	3.22	0.72	30.06	205.2×	OK	25.02	170.7×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	27.59 ~	31.00	30.33	0.50 ~	3.10	0.72	30.01	204.9×	OK	25.02	170.8×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	26.44 ~	29.41	29.35	0.62 ~	1.15	0.75	29.31	200.1×	OK	25.05	171.0×	OK
Transcend CF Ind. 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	36.74 ~	40.34	39.58	0.15 ~	0.84	0.48	42.57	290.5×	OK	30.65	209.2×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	37.75 ~	41.38	40.59	0.15 ~	0.87	0.48	41.98	286.5×	OK	27.89	190.4×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	28.84 ~	31.26	31.09	0.38 ~	2.98	0.76	31.04	211.9×	OK	23.00	157.0×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	28.89 ~	31.26	31.11	0.38 ~	2.85	0.76	31.02	211.7×	OK	22.81	155.7×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	29.42 ~	31.28	31.18	0.44 ~	1.45	0.81	30.83	210.4×	OK	22.47	153.4×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	25.81 ~	29.24	27.85	0.36 ~	3.40	0.83	27.71	189.1×	OK	24.16	164.9×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	23.26 ~	25.00	24.90	0.48 ~	1.59	0.84	24.89	169.8×	OK	22.06	150.6×	OK
SONY CF 300x 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	36.11 ~	39.95	39.35	0.16 ~	1.33	0.49	42.69	291.4×	OK	32.21	219.8×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	37.61 ~	41.14	40.77	0.15 ~	0.89	0.48	41.99	286.6×	OK	33.30	227.3×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	27.49 ~	31.25	30.47	0.37 ~	3.08	0.77	30.43	207.7×	OK	23.01	157.0×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	28.22 ~	31.25	30.87	0.38 ~	2.83	0.77	30.39	207.4×	OK	22.84	155.9×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	28.29 ~	31.25	31.06	0.38 ~	1.39	0.82	30.21	206.2×	OK	22.32	152.3×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	25.56 ~	29.29	27.85	0.40 ~	3.34	0.83	27.69	189.0×	OK	24.17	165.0×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	23.39 ~	25.01	24.89	0.49 ~	1.32	0.85	24.91	170.0×	OK	22.06	150.5×	OK
Lexar CF 300x 8GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	35.11 ~	39.05	38.24	0.16 ~	1.26	0.50	41.41	282.6×	OK	32.11	219.1×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	36.37 ~	40.21	39.62	0.15 ~	0.92	0.49	40.76	278.2×	OK	32.97	225.0×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	27.23 ~	31.25	30.09	0.37 ~	2.85	0.80	29.44	200.9×	OK	22.84	155.9×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	27.39 ~	31.15	29.63	0.37 ~	2.97	0.78	29.37	200.4×	OK	23.02	157.1×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	27.13 ~	31.13	30.08	0.38 ~	1.37	0.83	29.33	200.2×	OK	22.54	153.8×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	25.58 ~	28.12	27.68	0.44 ~	3.34	0.83	27.67	188.8×	OK	24.13	164.7×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	22.23 ~	25.00	24.39	0.47 ~	1.39	0.85	24.32	166.0×	OK	22.07	150.6×	OK
SanDisk CF Extreme IV 4GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
SanDisk Extr. FireWire 800	OXFW912-0604	36.12 ~	36.42	36.27	0.25 ~	0.73	0.39	40.41	275.8×	OK	33.87	231.2×	OK
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	36.00 ~	36.30	36.18	0.24 ~	1.08	0.39	40.39	275.7×	OK	33.85	231.1×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	36.73 ~	37.03	36.92	0.24 ~	0.92	0.38	40.06	273.4×	OK	34.19	233.3×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	29.06 ~	32.25	30.38	0.48 ~	2.71	0.68	31.10	212.3×	OK	24.67	168.4×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	29.12 ~	32.15	31.32	0.45 ~	2.85	0.68	31.10	212.2×	OK	24.63	168.1×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	28.97 ~	31.04	30.96	0.49 ~	1.31	0.68	30.96	211.3×	OK	24.72	168.7×	OK
Hama USB 2.0 UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	30.83 ~	31.03	30.97	0.48 ~	1.23	0.68	30.96	211.3×	OK	22.95	156.6×	OK
CompuApps UDMA Sample	xSil251:2.22	30.37 ~	31.04	30.97	0.49 ~	1.10	0.68	30.92	211.0×	OK	22.91	156.4×	OK
Kingston 19 in 1	GL826:9715	28.93 ~	31.03	30.80	0.54 ~	3.22	0.69	30.16	205.8×	OK	24.69	168.5×	OK
GL826 Sample	GL826:9714	28.90 ~	31.01	30.79	0.58 ~	3.22	0.69	29.88	203.9×	OK	24.64	168.2×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	28.93 ~	31.01	30.78	0.50 ~	3.22	0.69	29.71	202.8×	OK	24.64	168.2×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	28.78 ~	29.22	29.15	0.61 ~	1.37	0.75	29.31	200.0×	OK	24.67	168.4×	OK
Conrad 61-in-1 Multi	RTS5158_5195	28.47 ~	29.35	29.14	0.62 ~	1.27	0.75	29.29	199.9×	OK	24.73	168.8×	OK
CF Reader/Writer	AU6366-0604	18.19 ~	18.40	18.32	0.62 ~	1.41	0.81	18.48	126.1×	OK	17.53	119.6×	OK
takeMS 64 in 1 Mini	AU6371-0730	18.28 ~	18.48	18.38	0.61 ~	1.45	0.81	18.47	126.1×	OK	18.35	125.2×	OK
PIXO MINI-LC	AU6366-0603	18.18 ~	18.39	18.29	0.60 ~	1.35	0.81	18.47	126.0×	OK	17.50	119.4×	OK
Heisei Vantager HR-221	AU6375-0547	17.91 ~	18.25	18.12	0.61 ~	2.85	0.74	18.43	125.8×	OK	16.86	115.0×	OK
PIXO MSR-PRO	AU6375-0607	17.64 ~	18.38	17.99	0.51 ~	3.35	0.80	17.81	121.6×	OK	16.79	114.5×	OK
Hama 1000&1 Multi (9323)	H-GL819:9323	17.60 ~	17.87	17.80	0.62 ~	3.35	0.82	17.79	121.4×	OK	17.23	117.6×	OK
NEXTO CF ND-2500 1394a	OXFW911	13.65 ~	13.74	13.70	0.44 ~	1.32	0.62	14.97	102.1×	OK	12.16	83.0×	OK
Hama CardBus CF	VEN_1145-F021	12.36 ~	13.62	13.25	0.27 ~	0.91	0.45	13.66	93.2×	OK	8.38	57.2×	OK
CardBus CF	VEN_1145-F021	10.52 ~	13.24	12.41	0.30 ~	0.85	0.45	12.84	87.6×	OK	8.18	55.8×	OK
MSI StarReader 52 in 1	CS8819.110	12.06 ~	12.20	12.16	0.62 ~	3.09	0.81	12.15	82.9×	OK	12.01	81.9×	OK
A-Tec CF	GL813USB-0444	11.07 ~	11.11	11.10	0.47 ~	1.17	0.68	11.10	75.7×	OK	10.96	74.7×	OK
C-enter 12 in 1 Aluminium	GL816E:9138	8.23 ~	8.33	8.29	0.93 ~	5.96	1.19	8.31	56.7×	OK	7.97	54.4×	OK
C-enter 22 in 1 USB 2.0	OTi2126-0507	7.41 ~	7.46	7.44	0.62 ~	2.85	0.75	7.45	50.8×	OK	7.03	48.0×	OK
Hama 22 in 1 55116 (1.8D)	H-IC1210:1.8D	6.70 ~	6.76	6.73	0.86 ~	4.47	1.03	6.74	45.9×	OK	6.20	42.2×	OK
Hama MMS VSV-40 (1.07)	PS2002	4.44 ~	4.46	4.45	0.68 ~	3.09	0.94	4.45	30.3×	OK	4.37	29.8×	OK
Vivanco RW CF	GL813USB-0444													Under investigation
TwinMOS CF 300x 4GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
Hama FireWire 800	OXFW912-0637	23.82 ~	26.50	26.05	0.21 ~	5.04	0.68	27.68	188.9×	OK	18.37	125.4×	OK
Express/34 PCIe CF	PCIe	23.99 ~	26.96	26.49	0.20 ~	5.03	0.67	27.31	186.4×	OK	18.15	123.8×	OK
Digisol Multi 47200/01	UT335LF	21.25 ~	24.26	23.61	0.46 ~	5.37	0.95	23.51	160.5×	OK	17.55	119.8×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	21.33 ~	24.11	23.60	0.48 ~	5.25	0.95	23.51	160.5×	OK	17.67	120.6×	OK
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	21.37 ~	23.83	23.57	0.49 ~	5.37	0.99	23.27	158.8×	OK	17.68	120.7×	OK
Realtek RTS5158	RTS5158_5195	20.75 ~	23.81	23.12	0.59 ~	5.37	1.07	22.73	155.1×	OK	16.49	112.5×	OK
Digisol Multi 47100/10	GL826:9722	19.98 ~	23.81	22.82	0.50 ~	5.38	1.05	22.54	153.8×	OK	18.47	126.1×	OK
Transcend CF 133x 16GB		read			acc.			read			write			Comment
CompuApps USB UDMA CF	xSil251-G:2.22	25.37 ~	27.79	27.21	0.49 ~	5.10	3.00	27.17	185.5×	OK	10.78	73.5×	OK
Hama 35 in 1 V3	EI335LF	26.22 ~	27.81	27.61	0.38 ~	5.71	2.96	27.16	185.3×	OK	10.80	73.6×	OK

CARDSPEED - Card Readers and Memory Cards

Test Details, by Cards: Compact Flash, UDMA